Here are the best aftershave you can buy:
The best natural aftershave
Why you’ll love it: If you want to go au naturale, then you can’t beat the soothing and antiseptic properties of witch hazel, the main ingredient in Thayers’ renowned face toner.
If you’re at all familiar with skin care, then you’re likely no stranger to witch hazel. This North American herbal extract has been a staple of organic cosmetic products for centuries, prized for its natural ability to treat skin inflammation while featuring additional anti-bacterial properties, and it still remains a hugely popular natural alternative to synthetic topical solutions and antiseptics.Although witch hazel is cheap and undeniably effective, it doesn’t smell particularly nice. The Thayers’ face tonic is a great alternative to plain witch hazel, as it contains some additional ingredients that give it a pleasant fragrance while making it even more suited for use as an aftershave. Thayers is a historic 19th-century American brand that offers a number of all-natural facial tonics and skin toners, but with the additions of natural ingredients like aloe vera and vitamin E that work in conjunction with the witch hazel to refresh and soothe inflamed skin.We named Thayers our favorite natural face toner before, and although it’s not explicitly advertised as an “aftershave,” many men have nonetheless added this great formula to their wet shaving shelf. This is due to its all-natural ingredients and its undeniable effectiveness. After all, the purpose of a face toner is to clean the skin, close up pores, and soothe irritation, which is exactly what an aftershave should do, and Thayers checks all the boxes.Thayers offers its face toner in four different formulas. Our favorite of these contains additional rose water, which provides a nice fragrance while offering some additional skin-soothing effects along with the witch hazel. Thayers is completely free of alcohol, humectants, and parabens as well, and at $9 for a big 12-ounce bottle, it’s arguably the best value of all of our top picks.
Cons: Lacks the traditional masculine fragrances generally found in other aftershaves